Madison County is home to a rich variety of local pizza spots, each serving up unique pies that highlight the community’s diverse tastes. From cozy family-owned pizzerias to unique new eateries, there’s something for every pizza lover.
Art’s Pizza No. 1
Since 1956, Art’s Pizza has been a local favorite in Anderson, serving up fresh, mouth-watering pizzas and sandwiches. With two locations, Art’s Pizza combines history with quality, using only the freshest ingredients to create authentic, delicious meals in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere.
Featured on Indiana Foodways Za’ Pizza™ Trail
4762 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN
2027 Broadway St, Anderson, IN
Art’s Varsity Pizza
Owned by the same family behind Art’s Pizza, Art’s Varsity Pizza brings the same passion for fresh, flavorful pizzas and sandwiches to Anderson. With a focus on quality ingredients and friendly service, it’s a must-visit for anyone craving a delicious, locally owned meal.
2822 Main St, Anderson, IN
The Grill-A
A Markleville favorite, The Grill-A serves up crave-worthy pizzas with perfectly baked crusts, bold toppings, and unique flavor combinations. It’s a must-try stop for pizza lovers in Madison County.
Featured on Indiana Foodways Za’ Pizza™ Trail
4 W Main St, Markleville, IN 46056
INItaly Pizzeria and Bar
For a more luxurious pizza experience, INItaly Pizzeria and Bar serves authentic Neapolitan pizza, crafted with the finest ingredients. Owned by a member of the Catello family — known for their popular restaurant Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine in Pendleton — INItaly Pizzeria and Bar brings a taste of true Italian craftsmanship to Madison County.
Featured on Indiana Foodways Za’ Pizza™ Trail
107 E State Street, Pendleton, IN
Kroakerheads
A local favorite, Kroakerheads is known for its crowd-pleasing pizzas that keep people coming back. Loved by locals and perfect for a casual bite, it’s one of those spots everyone says you have to try.
Featured on Indiana Foodways Za’ Pizza™ Trail
1239 Meridian St, Anderson, IN 46016
Scampy’s Annex Pizza
Scampy’s Annex Pizza is a local favorite in Anderson, offering a casual and welcoming atmosphere perfect for lunch or dinner. Whether you’re craving a classic pizza, a savory pasta dish, or a satisfying sandwich, Scampy’s has something for everyone.
2705 Nichol Avenue, Anderson, IN
